The Rushmore Report: Hollywood, Spare Us Your Hypocrisy

Voters don’t take much notice of what Hollywood says about politics. If they did, Hillary Clinton would be president by now. What’s more, when Meryl Streep launched an attack on President Trump, it did not surprise. A Hollywood star unloading on a Republican? Seen it. Donald Trump responding with a Twitter counterattack on Twitter? Predictable.

No question, Streep’s recent emotional speech was delivered with tremendous dignity and made a very good point – one proven by Trump’s nasty reply. Even if he’s innocent of parodying people with disabilities, he’s upset plenty of minorities in his campaign for the White House. Some Mexican immigrants, remember, are “rapists” and “killers,” according to him. Black people should vote for him because they have nothing to lose. And so on.

But people are being lectured by Hollywood. Why? Partly it’s because Los Angeles is a strange, alien land full of beautiful eccentrics who use private jets like the rest of us use cabs. Partly because their politics are often far-left and absurd. But also because Hollywood is grossly hypocritical. The movie makers may hush over liberal causes at award ceremonies, but the industry they work in does not reflect those values. On the contrary, Hollywood can be just as regressive and conservative as Donald J. Trump.

For instance, it is estimated that 95 percent of characters with disabilities on TV are played by able-bodied actors. That’s pretty shameful. Actors with disabilities certainly exist and yes, Hollywood does make the occasional movie about the differently abled, such as the 2014 Stephen Hawking biopic The Theory of Everything. But that was a relatively low-budget movie designed to win awards, and the part was still played by a good looking, able-bodied actor so privileged that he went to Cambridge University with me.

What is rarer is to see an actor with a disability in a big-budget, leading-person role, or for Hollywood to make a mainstream movie about the day-to-day realities of a working-class person with a disability.

Their invisibility is not an isolated problem. For a country where 17.4 percent of Americans are of Latino heritage, it’s strange that they only make up an estimated 5.8 percent of characters in TV and film. Hollywood has tried to make up for the notorious dearth of Oscar nominations for people of color, and we should applaud recent movies like Hidden Figures that help redress this.

But let’s face it: Hollywood still undervalues African-American talent and audiences and has historically shied away from interracial relationships. And the movie industry still hires straight actors to play gay and transgender characters, which some see as a form of blackface.

Hollywood is about making money and its corporate, Trump-style ethic always wins in the end. For every Oliver Stone movie examining capitalism and war there are countless films that either glorify violence or exist to get us to buy something.

It is Hollywood that helped make Donald Trump. Hollywood crashed out apocalyptic superhero movies that burned into our consciousness the idea that the world is on fire – when it is actually safer than ever – and that only a strong man can put out the flames. Hollywood has also promoted cynicism, spinning a line in perpetual irony that encourages us to take everything as a cruel joke.

For years, movies and shows like Family Guy have been  encouraging us to laugh at pain and, yes, sometimes disability. Trump is the logical extension of this culture.

Meryl Streep is a genius, she was right about Trump and she has a right to say what she feels. But the collective smugness of Hollywood has to end. If it wants to change the world, it has to start with its own product. Make movies that solve problems with intelligence rather than force – and make heroes out of ordinary, complex people. Get that right and audiences will listen more to what actors have to say.

About the Author

Timothy Stanley is a historian and columnist for Britain’s Daily Telegraph, and author of Citizen Hollywood.

0 replies

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *